The Ankler

🎧 Jordan Firstman Swore Off Nihilism: ‘I Was Sick of It in Myself’

The ‘Club Kid’ star, writer and director’s unlikely move to win over boomers — and a $17 million A24 deal? Sincerity

I’m still on the road as the last rounds of awards-season Q&As roll out ahead of Thanksgiving break, but lucky for all of us, Christopher Rosen is ready and willing to take the reins. He joined me and Vanity Fair senior Hollywood correspondent Rebecca Ford for today’s episode of the Prestige Junkie podcast, where Rebecca and I shared everything we saw at Sunday’s jam-packed Governors Awards, and we all speculated about how the past week of frantic campaigning will affect the race ahead. 

Chris also took over for this week’s interview with the writer, director and star of one of the year’s best debut features — who we saw working the room on Sunday night as well. Chris, take it away!


Jordan Firstman was tired of the nihilism he was seeing everywhere.

“I was sick of it in myself. I didn’t want to feel like that anymore,” he says. “I wanted to believe in life again.”

Feeling lost and beaten down and, by his own admission, doing too many drugs (the comedowns were getting harder, he says), Firstman was nonetheless on the ascent. He had just starred as a fictionalized and exaggerated version of himself in the 2023 indie Rotting in the Sun and been cast as one of the leads on Rachel Sennott’s I Love LA. He’d even appeared in a recurring role on 2022’s Ms. Marvel. Not bad for a Long Island-born comedian and writer who found initial success by going viral on social media during the early days of the pandemic. 

But it wasn’t until he watched an acclaimed indie that his next act took shape.

“The movie was so good, and then — the millennial nihilism jumped out at the end. I was like, wow, you like totally didn’t need to do that,” Firstman, 35, says of the unnamed movie. That’s when he decided his next project would reject the idea that life means nothing — but without being corny. “I wanted to make something earnest,” he says. “We live these lives, and we try to be cool and fit in, but at the end of the day, we all want love, we all want acceptance, we all want to feel good, we wanna feel seen. That’s what I wanted to reflect.”

The result is Club Kid, Firstman’s acclaimed new film that premiered to raves at this year’s Cannes Film Festival, was quickly snapped up by A24 for $17 million and opened in early November — just after the Democrats won both chambers of Congress in the midterm elections and ushered in a renewed sense of hope among Gen Z and millennials. (“Our release happening the same week as the blue wave — intentional?” Firstman says. “A24 is good at what they do.”)

Written and directed by Firstman in his debut feature, Club Kid focuses on Peter (Firstman), a disillusioned gay club promoter and part-time drug dealer whose world is thrown off its axis when the 10-year-old son he never knew existed shows up on his doorstep. What starts as broad comedy as Peter tries to figure out how to take care of a child when he can barely take care of himself quickly morphs into something deeper and more genuine. It might be easy to blithely compare Club Kid to the Adam Sandler comedy Big Daddy — but with A24 indie taste — but Firstman’s influences included After Hours, Kramer vs. Kramer and An Unmarried Woman.

It wasn’t easy for him to hold the line. While writing the script, Firstman says he constantly battled his internal monologue, which told him the emotional earnestness he was putting into the script wasn’t cool.

“But if I got to the other side, I knew I was going to thank myself because it is something I’m not seeing right now — and I think people need it,” he says. “We need to stop feeling like we can’t get above it; that these are our shitty lives now and we deal with it. We can see it happening with the blue wave — hope exists, and we can make that happen and we can make that happen within ourselves, too. So that’s what I think the movie is ultimately about: taking control.”

Maybe that’s why a movie that, on its face, might turn off older, more conservative viewers — Firstman doesn’t shy away from depicting excessive drug use and casual sex — played so well on the festival circuit, which overindexes on boomers. Following its Cannes buy, A24 held Club Kid for the fall festivals, relaunching it at Telluride before stops in Toronto and New York. In Telluride, perhaps the most boomer-centric of all the festivals, Firstman says 70-year-olds came up to him praising the movie.

But he wasn’t surprised. “A 70-year-old lived through the ’70s and ’80s — everyone living now has some relationship to drugs, to partying,” he says. “So I think even 70-year-olds are seeing this and thinking about their 20s, and like thinking about how they raised their kids.”

Still, Firstman says Club Kid has connected particularly strongly with fathers (count me as guilty; this movie made me cry my eyes out!).

“I think there’s something in the relationship between Peter and his son that every father wishes they had with their kid — which is honesty,” he says. “I think a lot of dads specifically probably watched this and wish they had that with their kids — especially if the relationships have become distant or fractured. Maybe that is the thing that would have kept them together: both of them knowing that the other person was a person.”

Comments

Only Ankler All Access subscribers can comment

Already a subscriber?

Related Stories