The Ankler.

The Ankler.

Share this post

The Ankler.
The Ankler.
A24 Enters the Uncanny Valley
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
Richard Rushfield

A24 Enters the Uncanny Valley

Can the beloved indie escape the grow-too-big trap? Plus: Sundance stress, 'Harper's' discovers Hollywood

Richard Rushfield's avatar
Richard Rushfield
Apr 18, 2024
∙ Paid
21

Share this post

The Ankler.
The Ankler.
A24 Enters the Uncanny Valley
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
1
Share
SWAN DIVE A24 lost a bit of indie cool-kid cred with its AI-generated promotional images for Civil War. (A24)

Share

Two days ago, in my compilation of things that are inevitable in Hollywood, I wrote, “The scrappy indie studio that has success with good taste and smart marketing gets cocky, ups its budgetary spending, and then crashes and burns.”

Many assumed I was talking about A24 when I wrote that, but I was really more generally thinking of every independent would-be mini-studio since the dawn of Hollywood — from the original United Artists on down to Miramax. 

There’s a reason no one has created a studio to rival the majors that has lasted since the dawn of Hollywood and up until this very moment: Moviemaking is a terrible, unpredictable business, and if your bets start getting too big, you put everything wildly at risk. Everybody hits a cold streak eventually. Everybody. The cost of losing everything on a bunch of movies in a row is the real barrier to entry.

So A24 had a massive hit this weekend. Well, massive by intramural standards. Its biggest opening. The biggest film of the weekend. All well and good, but a $25 million opening on a budget of $50 million? 60? 70? That sounds more like a bullet dodged than a runaway success.

Which is fine. Good for them if they can break even on a midrange movie. Thing is, A24 is still acting like a little micro-budget indie. It’s still being held to the standards of a micro-budget indie where any trace of success is a giant victory.

But it’s not making films like a micro-budget indie. In recent months, the scrappy upstart is consistently taking some big swings — moving out of the indie sphere and into that dangerous middle range where Lionsgate lives. And the results through that lens are not so spectacular.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Ankler Media
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More